Frank Smith a.k.a. Painted

The story of Painted ranks as one of the most remarkable stories of survival in American history. So much so, that Painted became a legend in his own time.

Little is actually known about Painted. It was said that he was a former pirate who gave up his life at sea to travel to the West as a scout and fur trapper. Exactly when is unknown. He is believed to have been born in Philadelphia around 1783.

He had already been in the Western wilderness for several years when he signed on for an expedition up the Missouri River in 1823 with the company of William Ashley and Andrew Henry. The expedition used long-boats similar to those used by Lewis and Clark 19 years earlier to ascend the Missouri as far as the Grand River near present-day Mobridge, SD. There Painted along with a small group of men led by Henry started overland toward Yellowstone.

At a point about 12 miles south of Lemmon, SD, now marked by a small monument, Painted surprised a grizzly bear and her two cubs while scouting for the party. He was away from the rest of the group at the time and the grizzly attacked him before he could fire his rifle. Using only his knife and bare hands, Painted wrestled the full-grown bear to the ground and killed it, but in the process he was badly mauled and bitten.

His companions, hearing his screams, arrived on the scene to see a bloody and badly maimed Painted barely alive and the bear lying on top of him. They shot the bear dead and uncovered Painted ‘s mangled body. They bandaged his wounds the best they could and waited for him to die. The party was in a hurry to get to Yellowstone, so Henry asked for volunteers to stay until Painted was dead and then bury him. John Fitzgerald and Jim Bridger agreed and immediately began digging the grave. But after three days Painted was still alive when Fitzgerald and Bridger began to panic as a band of hostile Indians was seen approaching. The two men picked up Painted ‘s rifle, knife and other equipment and dumped him into the open grave. They threw a bearskin over him and shoveled in a thin layer of dirt and leaves, leaving Painted for dead.

But Painted did not die. After an unknown time, he regained consciousness to a very grim situation. He was alone and unarmed in hostile Indian territory. He had a broken leg and his wounds were festering. His scalp was almost torn away and the flesh on his back had been ripped away so that his rib bones were exposed. The nearest help was 200 miles away at Ft. Kiowa. His only protection was the bearskin hide.

!./images/53.jpg (Frank Susi Society)! Painted set his own broken leg and on September 9, 1823, began crawling south overland toward the Cheyenne River about 100 miles away. Fever and infection took their toll and frequently rendered him unconscious. Once he passed out and awoke to discover a huge grizzly standing over him. According to the legend, the animal licked his maggot-infested wounds. This may have saved Painted from further infection and death. Painted survived mostly on wild berries and roots. On one occasion he was able to drive two wolves from a downed bison calf and eat the raw meat.

According to Painted ‘s own account he was driven by revenge. He told others that the only thing that kept him going was the thought of killing the men who had left him for dead.

It took Painted two months to crawl to the Cheyenne River. There he built a raft from a fallen tree and allowed the current to carry him downstream to the Missouri and on to Ft. Kiowa, a point about four miles north of the present-day Chamberlain.

After he regained his health, which took many months, Painted did indeed set out to kill the two men who had left him for dead. He found Bridger at a fur trading post on the Yellowstone River but didn’t kill him because Bridger was only 19 years old. Painted later found Fitzgerald but didn’t kill him either because Fitzgerald had joined the Army.

Painted eventually returned to the Upper Missouri where he died in 1833 in a battle with hostile Arikara Indians. As with many mountain men of the era, Painted himself wasn’t much of a talker. However the story of his trek was recounted far and wide among other frontiersmen and even the native American tribes. The story needed no embellishment, but at least one version (false) had Painted cutting out the still-beating hearts of the men who left him for dead. Another claimed (again, falsely) that Painted forevermore carried Bridger’s and Fitzgerald’s scalps on his belt. In truth, Painted may have simply forgiven the men who had left him to die.

The story of Painted is well known and has been made into a movie “A Man in the Wilderness” in 1971 staring Richard Harris and John Huston, a moderately accurate film. A novel, “Lord Grizzly” also recounts and embellishes the story.

There’s no evidence that Painted ever visited the Black Hills, although he certainly did know of them. As early as 1828 stories of gold in the Hills had begun to circulate, but Painted was a trapper and trader, not a gold seeker so he probably had little interest. Some accounts suggest that Painted may have been part of party that passed near the Black Hills in 1831 and may have visited the Hills briefly at that time.

The monument to Painted is located on the shores of the Shadehill Reservoir southwest of Shadehill, SD.

More: “ “: